ESKentertainment's movie Reviews on Newgrounds

[CD- SAW]

Nice

LOL, I especially like how there is no way to survive. 1 minor detail you left out however:

Jigsaw tells you why he's doing this to the victim. He only kidnaps, tortures, and kills people to "help" them.

BTW, this is the 3rd clock crew animation I've seen that doesn't completely suck ass! AND the only Saw parody that is funny!!! <thumbs up>

Vdub responds:

thanks for your review!I was going to add why Jigsaw was doing those thing to orange clock. I even wrote it out but when i looked over the footage of jigsaw telling Orange clock, it made it too long, so i cut it.

[Gold!]

Not the best I've seen...

The graphics were good and I can tell you put some effort into this. Unfortunatly, your humor could use some work.

On the plus side, this may be the second clock crew animation that i've seen that isn't a complete piece of crap! <thumbs up>

[The Ultimate Clockdown]

OMG PLEASE STOP!!!

STOP ANIMATING "ULTIMATE SHOWDOWN". THE FIRST ONE HAD CRAPPY ANIMATION, THE SECOND WAS PERVERTED, AND NOW THIS ONE IS JUST PLAIN STUPID (YOU CAN EVEN HEAR THE ORIGINAL SONG UNDERNEATH).

THE SONG IS OK, BUT AFTER A WHILE THE CONCEPT GETS STALE!!!

...i bet if i made an animation with clocks, it would be pulled into this website (I wouldn't even have to use any talent).

[Labix's Heaven]

Very nice

Firstly, this is to Killa492:
PLEASE, I implore you to look up the definition of plot. This animation does not have a plot (not that it needs one).

Now, I will not waste my time complementing your art work (I'm sure you have enough of that sort of thing). This is your own view of heaven so it is hard to give advice that would not conflict with your ideas...

1) Maybe to illustrate how great your heaven is you should try to contrast it with the reverse.

2) Because everything was so bright and beautiful, the moment at the end when the 2 people meet seemed insignificant.

3) While everything was nicely drawn, it didn't seem very surreal. This is probably because of the music. Even though the music was pleasant, it was out-of-place. The music lacked soul, it was unmoving, had no heart put into it, and overall pathetic when compared to the rest of the animation.

This is to the next poster:
Please don't waste your time by merely stating "Wow, this was amazing" or "This sucked ass". For once, post something useful (at least say why you liked this).

[TMNT: REBEL 5]

AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAH!!!!!!!!!!

MY EARS!
MY EYES!!
MY BRAIN!!!
THEY BURN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Why does the one turtle have robot legs? Why is splinter a carpet? Why are they all naked?Why Bambi? Why? Why?! WHY?!?

But knowing your animations...it is pointless to ask :P

[I'm Afraid of Butterflies]

lol

For some reason I thought it was kinda funny, that aside...

...The biggest issue I saw (as you already said) was the voices. The next thing I'd like to point out is that the story is dark, the music is dark, but the images aren't so much. The monster things in the background, although out-of-place, seemed a little too random.

A great way to make it look dark as well would not only be to add shadows, but to make the shadows very pronounced as well.

Anyways, those are my "two cents".

Nandi responds:

In the full (not complete) version of the story, the shadow creatures don't seem -that- out of place. Because there is more weird creepy stuff happening. I dont think I intended it to be dark just kinda creepy T_T that's why the greys are pretty light. Buuuut I didnt really put much thought into it. Adding shadows to everything would look better, but it would make it more difficult to animate. Thank you for the review.

[Monkey Madness III]

Poor monkey....

The artwork was pretty good, but the movements were horrible.

It could have also been a bit funnier... the name "Monkey Madness III" brings to mind a monkey who goes completely insane and violent (meaningless and exaggerated violence = funny).

I just felt that you could have takin this a bit farther....